The death of competitive advantage: How Apple Maps drove off the road

Apple's decision to include homegrown Apple Maps in its latest iPhone offering demonstrates a huge process-fail lesson for CIOs.

One consistent thread in the scores of iPhone 5 reviews has been mention of how the native Apple Maps in iOS6 are...

an undeniable downgrade. Users of previous iOS incarnations enjoyed Google Maps technology, which was featured prominently in the very first iPhone ads back in 2007. In the development of the latest iOS, Apple developers pushed hard to deliver voice-activated, turn-by-turn navigation to their native Apple Maps -- and, in that respect, they made good on that goal.

Wendy SchuchartWendy Schuchart

Unfortunately, in a broader sense, the new Apple iOS 6 maps just don't deliver. What we have here is a massive quality breach with actual health and safety implications -- not to mention the unbelievable cost of fossil fuels and the environmental impact of carbon emissions exhausted by people driving around in circles based on the crazy directions given by Apple Maps.

For instance, the new maps think that much of the east side of Portland, Ore., is a nature reserve; and the satellite image is even worse -- it looks like a scene from the movie Inception. Lest you think that Portland is a special case, it's not. Entire major tourist attractions in Europe are missing, the Statue of Liberty vanished, malls have been misplaced and highways are shown going off into bodies of water. Even worse, the maps depict bridges where there aren't any bridges. This PR nightmare has even inspired the Twitter hashtag #iOS6apocalypse, where iPhone 5 users report their own crazy mishaps with the new Apple Maps.

More consumerization news and tips for CIOs

The Apple Maps aren't the only problem with the new iPhone 5

Digital media strategies make or break CIO initiatives

Mobile apps crucial to building customer relationships

Apple should have used a mobile-friendly website for its navigation feature

Our favorite Android business apps are 100% free

As someone who relies upon her iPhone for navigation, it's pretty terrible. I really don't care that the Apple Maps images make trees look like giant stalks of broccoli or make the Las Vegas Strip look like a Salvador Dali painting -- I just want a map that I can trust to get me from here to there safely and efficiently.

Why did CEO Tim Cook decide to abandon Google Maps in favor of developing its own? It comes down to vendor management. Google was already delivering turn-by-turn navigation to Android phones, yet it hadn't begun working on turn-by-turn voice navigation maps for the iPhone 5. The Verge's Chris Ziegler reported that Apple still had more than a year remaining on its Google Maps contract, but chose to not to take advantage of this remaining time period.

Strategically, I'm not terribly surprised that Apple chose to end the relationship in an effort to keep up with Android's technology (or block Google from having more control and branding in Apple's biggest offering). However, from a quality standpoint, Apple has essentially thrown the baby away with the bathwater. The lack of voice turn-by-turn navigation is, admittedly, a minor nuisance, but certainly not the deal breaker that Apple executives envisioned. And, as a consumer, let's face it -- bad maps are worse than having no maps at all.

This huge PR nightmare serves as a valuable strategic lesson for CIOs in similar product development projects. In Apple's rush to alleviate a strategic pain-point, company heads forgot one vital piece of information: IPhone users weren't really willing to sacrifice reliable maps for the luxury of a voice that tells us when to turn (especially when that voice is telling us to turn in the middle of an overpass). Apple demonstrated that it was willing to sacrifice the quality of a product in order to make a swipe at gaining competitive advantage in the marketplace.

But Apple has also suffered unexpected costs thanks to this decision – a lesson that CIOs can take to heart. For years, Apple has practically trained its users to have a cult-like trust in its products. But now, with Apple maps, navigation no longer "just works." To paraphrase mobile industry blogger Ewan MacLeod, second-guessing an Apple product didn't even occur to me. Apple's strongest intangible feature was the trust it had built by always delivering a painstakingly tested product.

When reacting to competitors, CIOs need to make sure they aren't sacrificing their end goals in a fruitless, un-vetted effort to gain competitive advantage.

Let us know what you think about the story; email Wendy Schuchart, site editor. For midmarket IT news and updates throughout the week, follow us on Twitter @ciomidmarket.

Dig Deeper on Small-business infrastructure and operations

PRO+

Content

Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

Join the conversation

9 comments

Send me notifications when other members comment.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy

Please create a username to comment.

What lessons can we learn from Apple's maps issue?
Cancel
Something about reinventing the wheel
Cancel
Surely there must be a case for a class action against Apple in this. It is not just the maps but all the other apps that link to them that will become unreliable
Cancel
The bigest reason for me not to go to IO6 on my iPhone 4s is the map issue. I have other reasons not to switch to the iPhone 5 altogether: The issue of planned obsolescence and the fact that the phones are upgraded yearly but I have a 2-year contract.
Cancel
Should have carried on with goggle while perfecting thier own which could have given them a good jump. Now thier effort isnt green at all and its the least expected from Apple.
Cancel
It is inconceivable that Apple Executives did not know of these flaws and even more glaring is their decision to proceed if they knew about the flaws. Dumb. Agree with comments already posted. They should have used the extra year to mature their software. I have a 3GS and I am not going to upgrade until the map issue is fixed. I use this app a lot so I may even consider moving on to the Android platform
Cancel
shame !
Cancel
they have to get their act together or die together
Cancel
I believe Apple's decision was a strategic and tactical blunder. One major intangible has been lost and may never be regained with this seemingly ill-thought-through act. They truly didn't consider the consumer. Is this the beginning of a policy shift? Does this spell the beginning of the end of their unquestioned dominance in the consumer space?
Cancel

-ADS BY GOOGLE

SearchCompliance

SearchHealthIT

SearchCloudComputing

SearchMobileComputing

SearchDataCenter

Close