The social networking revolution will go only as far as the people

The social networking revolution is upon us, but will it change business for the better? It will go only as far as the people participating in it.

For every person who has jumped on a bandwagon -- or on a meme, in today's language -- there's one or two people...

asking to get off the "social networking revolution," or preferring to not get on at all.

Scot PetersenScot Petersen,
editorial director,
SearchCIO.com

Think Seinfeld's Kramer with the AIDS ribbon, or Bartleby, the Scrivener: A Story of Wall-street. Today we have Andrew Keen (aka @ajkeen, the self-described “antichrist of Silicon Valley”) with his new book, Digital Vertigo: How Today's Online Social Revolution Is Dividing, Diminishing, and Disorienting Us.

I've been reading the book, and I should say right at the top that anyone interested in social media, for or against, should read this book (I have the iPad Kindle app version). It's a fascinating, complicated and controversial treatise on social networks, the right to privacy, and what it all says about how we perceive ourselves as human beings.

Here's a sample:

"Today's social media is actually splintering our identities so that we always exist outside ourselves, unable to concentrate on the here-and-now, too wedded to our own image, perpetually revealing our current location, our privacy sacrificed to the utilitarian tyranny of a collective network."

This is strong stuff, conjuring concepts of the tyranny of the majority that democratic systems of government try to control, for instance, through the balance of power. In the Twitterverse, there is no balance of power, only how many followers I have and how cool my hashtags are. But Keen's not writing as a Luddite: He's a technology entrepreneur, author and above all, a social media user.

Wanted: A social CIO

Why should this kind of heresy be interesting to CIOs and other senior IT leaders? Because now you are being told you must get on the bandwagon, and there's little you can do about it. You've been reading about social business strategy and bring-your-own-device, or BYOD policies in the pages of SearchCIO.com. Forrester Research recently came out with a report titled The Social CIO. Even President Obama has taken to social media in order to get closer to the people.

In the Twitterverse, there is no balance of power, only how many followers I have and how cool my hashtags are.

Scot Petersen,
editorial director, SearchCIO.com

There's a method to this madness, of course. Social networks enable businesses to be closer to their people -- the customers -- in ways they've never had before, "to help their business design and build end-to-end experiences for customers … and to better understand how to influence customers, build better products and improve operations," writes Forrester senior analyst TJ Keitt, author of The Social CIO report.

I agree with all of that, and even have made similar recommendations myself, especially concerning the use social media tools for collaboration in the enterprise. But you have to admit that there's an insidious nature to the "collective network," as Keen calls it. If you aren't part of it, you're out of the loop, and so the pressure is on to be "on" all the time. Even if you do participate, your chances of becoming an alpha male in the virtual world are about as good as becoming one in the real world. Talent will win out, whatever the medium of choice.

Social revolutionaries

So, where can we go with this new insight on the social networking revolution? Recognize that it is a revolution, for one. In the case of empowering the customer and the knowledge worker, it's a revolution that is probably long overdue. But to what end is it a revolution?

Should businesses start crowdsourcing out all market research and product development? Maybe, but what would that say about a company's own agenda, ethics and capacity for innovation? Where would we strike the balance? Should enterprise IT staffs force their own social technology on their users or should employees take to communicating only through (socially) approved channels rather than those supplied by enterprise IT?

These are tough calls, and are not going to be solved here and now. But the success or failure of transforming business around social models will rest on them. And the decisions are going to need to be made soon.

Dig Deeper on Enterprise mobile strategy

PRO+

Content

Find more PRO+ content and other member only offers, here.

Join the conversation

6 comments

Send me notifications when other members comment.

By submitting you agree to receive email from TechTarget and its partners. If you reside outside of the United States, you consent to having your personal data transferred to and processed in the United States. Privacy

Please create a username to comment.

Is social networking going to change business as we know it?
Cancel
As CIO and 33 year technologist, I am certain social dramatically changes the way we do business. The objective of business will not change - make money, create value, do good or do evil, but the transparency and mode for the transaction has already dramatically changed. Social is a much more important phenomenon than "the cloud" or "SOA", which are mostly hype and repackaged 80s IT concepts.
Cancel
The lemming approach to this social media phenomenon worries me. We are less than 5 years into it and people act as if it's the only way to interact. Humans have several millenia's worth of interacting without it, and methinks all it will take is a one month solar flare blip to take it all down permanently. Not a bad idea, actually. Now that we understand it, can we have a restart? A man is in prison because of his tweets and private FB pages. Empty-headed celebrities are clogging up the cyber airspace with their ridiculous vanity tweets. Privacy, dignity, equilibrium and common sense have gone out the window.

Just as we used to urge families to turn off the TV for a week, we need all the social media to turn off for a week. It would do us all a lot of good, and bring a few "cyber-entrepreneurs" down a deserved notch or two.

It's a fantasy world where nothing is tangible, nothing is verifiable. It's no wonder this population thinks printing money out of thin air is acceptable.

We are lost.
Cancel
It is inevitable and is only a matter of time (not long) before organizations embrace the new way to connect and harness the power of the collective. All apps will go social and bigger, better stronger insights will emerge from the conversations in a sociallly networked enterprise - from people to processes to apps.
Cancel
It will take some time and it is true in long prospects.
Cancel
I think you asked the wrong question – or perhaps the right question the wring way – and in so doing simply reinforced the mindless herd mentality of group think inherent in much of social networking.

In my opinion, what you should have asked is whether Social Networking will change the nature of business as “I” know it. And from my perspective the answer is still NO.

I don’t need to be social to do business, I merely need to know what I need rather than what others (including biased search engine results) tell me what I should want.

If business had to be anything, I’d prefer it to be more civil, not more social.
Cancel

-ADS BY GOOGLE

SearchCompliance

SearchHealthIT

SearchCloudComputing

SearchMobileComputing

SearchDataCenter

Close